Hybrid street/all terrain pickup tire

[Rangerscott]

So one of my rear tires decided to separate on the highway coming home yesterday. They're old and shit happens.

I'm driving a 1993 F150 (235/75r15) and it's just a drive pickup now, but I don't want straight street tread. Also I don't want to spend a ton on tires because once I get my samurai running this will just be used when I need the bed or haul something. It's too much of a gas guzzler to drive daily.

I've called a few places and the Goodyear Wrangler popped up twice. I'm guessing the "radial" model since I was quoted $412 + tax installed. There's other models but they're over $120 a tire.

What else is a good hybrid tire? Would like to keep them under $500 installed but will go a bit more if need be.